I tried to solve this question I arrived at this diagram but taking the moments about the center of the beam I arrived at x=L/2. Can someone tell me what I need to do to get the correct answer?
-
2If you show your working so far - we may be able to help... – Solar Mike Feb 03 '18 at 16:37
-
2Welcome to Engineering! This looks like a [homework question](http://meta.engineering.stackexchange.com/q/121/1832). As mentioned by Solar Mike, in order for such questions to be answered in this site, we need you to show how you have tried to solve this yourself. Please [edit] your question to include this information. – Wasabi Feb 03 '18 at 16:58
-
Following your edit, I have recommended this question to be reopened. That being said, see [my answer to a similar question](https://engineering.stackexchange.com/a/12986/1832) for the solution. – Wasabi Feb 07 '18 at 18:02
1 Answers
Second Attempt:
After reading your comments, I approached the problem using a different process.
Step 1: Find the y-forces using $\Sigma$$F_y = 0$.
$(2\cdot Tsin(\theta))$ - $(W\cdot L)$ $=0$
$2Tsin(\theta)$ = $WL$
Step 2: Treat the beam as a collection of beams.
I decided to break the beam into three parts. The outside edges can be thought of as cantilever beams that are attached by the supports.
Step 3: Making the first cut at the midpoint to the left support.
Using the formula for bending moment of a simple beam under a uniformly distributed load, we can determine that $M_{mid} = \frac{WS^2}{8}$
Step 4: Making the second cut at the left sling.
Using the formula for bending moment of a cantilever beam under a uniformly distributed load, we can determine that $M_{cantilever} = \frac{Wx^2}{2}$
Step 5: Setting equations equal and solving.
From left end, to get the sum of moments to equal zero, $M_{cantilever} = \frac{M_{mid}}{2}$
Therefore:
$\frac{WS^2}{16} =\frac{Wx^2}{2}$
$WS^2=8Wx^2$
$S^2=8x^2$
$S = 2\sqrt{2}x$
Final:
As you can see, the center span $S = 2\sqrt{2}x$. Because $S = L-2x$, you can substitute to find the equation $L-2x = 2\sqrt{2}x$
$L = 2\sqrt{2}x + 2x$
$L \approx 4.8284x$
$x \approx \frac{1}{4.8284L} \approx 0.2071L$
_
Where $x$ is the distance from a support on the beam to the left end of the beam.
Where $S$ is the span of the beam.
Where $L$ is the length of the beam.
To clarify, the beam of length $L$ is divided into three sections; the left cantilever of length $x$, the center span $S$ of length $L-2x$, and the right cantilever of length $x$.
Where $Tsin(\theta)$ is y-component of the tension force.
Where $W$ is the weight of the beam.
- 156
- 1
- 3
-
-
-
-
A different approach led to the solution above. Less intuition is needed and more practice, I guess. – Cardinal Feb 08 '18 at 01:01


